- Joined
- Sep 18, 2007
- Posts
- 13,430
You really putting DDT up there?
DDT is a good product because they know what they want to be and everything they put on screen or in the ring is in service of that. DDT is nothing like ROH but they have the same level of commitment to their identity so, just like Lucha Underground, the nonsense stuff they do actually works for them. I can't say I watch every DDT show, nor even most of them. But I know what to expect when I do watch it and they do their best to deliver on that promise. DDT does all kinds of stupid shit but I don't recall them putting on a terrible show. DDT stands for Dramatic Dream Team; with a name like that you know you're not getting NJPW and their "King of Sports" mentality. And that's why their new owners are keeping NOAH, which is relatively serious, separate from DDT. Unlike WWE which just arbitrarily divides people up between shows that are the same shit, there's a coherent reason for a brand split here.
NXT, for example, can't even decide what it is. Is it developmental? Is it a third brand? Is the NXT title a world title? Is it a sports based promotion? If so, why is Karen Q being repackaged as a 1000 year old character from Chinese mythology? I don't think a single person in WWE can answer those questions because the real reason NXT exists is to hoard talent away from the other majors. Roderick Strong has been there five excruciating years and he's not having the same quality of matches he did in ROH and Japan through no fault of his own. Same goes for Cole, Fish, O'Reilly, etc. They still put on good matches but the magic is gone and sometimes it feels like they're just going through the motions.
Impact was great when the Knockouts and the X-Division were killing it every week, and that's the time in their history when they were the closest to having their own identity. Because for most of their existence their identity was simply "opposition to WWE" which resulted in a gong show because WWE itself has no identity and it's always stupid to define your product by a competitor's in the first place.
AEW literally was pitched as a sports-based promotion where wins and losses mattered and there'd be no cringey ass WWE shit. They promised us NJPW and ROH style with a major network budget. Instead we're getting a show with a bunch of unrelated concepts trying to pander to every distinct style of wrestling fan in the same two hours and as a result nobody really gets what they want. The rankings are meaningless, the rules aren't enforced, the camera work is just like WWE's, Matt Hardy can fucking teleport, geezers are wrestling on PPV, Chris Jericho is doing musical dance numbers, and all the while JR is burying the roster and plugging his diarrhea BBQ sauce and shitty podcast while Excalibur tries to call the matches like a real fight. And the Young Bucks are booking all their talentless friends like Peter Avalon, Luther, Michael Nakazawa, etc.