- Joined
- Sep 4, 2011
- Posts
- 3,624
lol, I got downvoted to oblivion on reddit for saying 'I didn't like The Wind Rises, it was too boring and never picked up.' People thought I was trolling, too, when I was just...stating my opinion.
I understand everyone feels strongly about Miyazaki-sama and all, but that movie did not resonate with me at all.
Looking forward to seeing what Ren thinks, despite if he agrees with me or not.
So, I finally got a chance to sit down and watch The Wind Rises yesterday, and I loved it! I can see where you're coming from as the pace was pretty even all the way through with only a couple of minor blips where the pace crept up briefly, but I did find the story and subject matter fascinating. My wife started off finding it boring and not being able to relate, but her tune changed quickly within the first quarter of the film.
That being said, I found many of the transitions through time to be jarring, not knowing that sizable chunks of time had passed in Jiro 's life between scenes until a minute or two into each one; it threw me off a bit when trying to make sense of a scene's direction. The sound effects for the planes made me laugh at times. I'm not sure why the Foley artist/team chose to go with mouthed sfx for engines sputtering and blades spinning, but it was obvious and broke the suspension of disbelief more than once.
As usual, the animation was a master class on painted backgrounds, fluidity of motion, understanding of colour, and warmth with the earthquake scene being the most technically challenging and amazing scene in the film: the scores of people moving all around, the chaos of it all is a supreme challenge (ordered chaos) in hand drawn animation, and it was obvious that no short cuts were taken; every character was meticulously drawn and had a purpose. One of the other major highlights to the film was the soundtrack; another Ghibli classic. It was also an interesting choice to, at points, have no music at all and instead let the wind be the soundtrack; a fitting choice for certain scenes.
Stories like this really resonate with me, and I find there's a certain mystique about World War II, from it's heroes to it's villains, and everything in between. It's also interesting to see the realty of the sacrifice necessary to reach for one's dreams presented here insofar as having to accept we can't always reach our goals with the purity that we imagined we could or would.
The movie had a lot of heart and character for me, so I'm a fan and feel that it is an instant classic, but like a wrote at the beginning, I can understand how it's not necessarily for everyone.
Last edited: