GigaDrive said:
I've longed for CD-in-a-caddy type of media, if we cannot have some form of optical disc that is far faster than CD or DVD. I mean, why has it not happened?
Me too
... Well I guess if there is no demand for it, then it will not happen. People just seem unaware or don't care about the benefits of having optical discs inside cartridges. Not only would they be more durable, protect against direct sunlight, scratchproof, but also have more room nice label art
.
While in the early days of CDROMS caddies were clumsy, it should have later become standard to have optical discs inside cartridges (now it is too late to do anything about that). Minidiscs evolved in the right direction, with all discs built inside a cartridge/caddie. I think it is crazy that DVD did not follow that direction, the first blue ray disc prototypes are inside cartridges/caddies. But they will probably end up being "naked discs" for the consumer market just like DVD's and CD's to maintain backward compatibility. I guess having the discs inside a cartridge would make it cost like $1 more per discs, well worth it in my opinion for all games.
One interesting thing though is that Sonys PSP is going to use a proprietary Sony disc called the UMD, the UMD is a disc format enclosed in a small cartridge (similar to the Sony Mini-Disc format.) Hopefully some kind of similar disc in a cartridge format is developed even for next generation of fullsize consoles. Although I guess again backward compatibility could prevent that.
But eventually I predict they will be forced to put optical discs into cartridges, if the media is going to spin any faster or have denser data (as they would have to make them spin stably, and even small scratches could ruin a lot of the data).