That is pretty much where I'm at. Especially when you look at the possibilities with higher end digital formats. 5.1 channels and true reproduction of digitally recorded albums.
Hell, people talk about how vinyl is theoretically superior, but it can't even handle two completely independent channels.
Tons of people confuse "different" with "better/worse".
I sold mid-end home theater equipment for a few years, people would always ask me what sounds "best". I'd often reply with "Well, what kind of meat tastes "best" to you?"
Tastes vary, what you want to hear varies. Analog media and digital media sound different...but one being "better" than the other in terms of quality? Hard telling. I will say that digital media is the same, every time. I can definitely appreciate that.
I tell younger people this, I've been there and done that, I don't want t do it again. I've struggled with vinyl, tape cassettes, VHS, Laserdisc. I don't want to go back.
Dirty vinyl, flipping record sides, the needle being of, the table being off, audible pops and cracks...
Dirty/worn cassettes, background noise, machines eating a tape...
VHS PQ (even when new), lackluster audio quality, dirty players, worn out tapes...
Laserdisc players being out of level, video noise, bad discs, laser rot, swapping disc sides, swapping discs...
I don't want to fuck with any of that stuff anymore. My Blu Ray discs work every time and deliver the same performance every time. Digital audio offers great sound quality and you know for a fact the delivery is exactly the same, every time. On top of that...accessibility is not even comparable. I load my phone up with MP3's. Pop headphones in and bam...massive music library anywhere I go. No tapes, no CDs. I get in my car and my phones syncs Bluetooth and again, instant library access.
In short...Nostalgia? Sure, why not. Functionality? No fucking way.