Not sure how comparable it is, but I have a HRAP1 that no longer has Hori buttons in it. The Sanwa stick inside felt a little eccentric compared to what I was used to, as it has a wide throw and it can be hard feeling out the directions at first (you hear but can't feel the click of the microswitches as the stick hits each direction), but once you get used to it it really is a terrific stick, exceptionally good for 3D fighters and fairly good for 2D fighters too. As for the Hori stock buttons that came with it, they're fairly good, but I prefer looser buttons personally, so I switched them for Sanwas. Most people won't have a problem with them, I expect. The actual case is sturdy, but the mirrored surface of the HRAP1 scratches easily. Maybe better to get the slightly more expensive HRAP2 which has a normal surface.