SCARLET
It was released to theaters last week on IMAX and this week to general theaters so I went and saw it with the roomie.
I legitimately had no real interest in seeing this film other than because it was an anime on the big screen that wasn't a gay shonen battle anime, an isekai or something with horse girls racing.
The film is about a girl that dies regretting not being able to avenge her father, who was betrayed by his brother, his crown and wife stolen and then executed after they lied about him being a traitor working with the country's enemies. The titular character, Scarlet, is transported to a sort of purgatory called 'Otherworld' where souls go to try and make their way to the 'infinite land', an escape from the desolate realm they are currently in to something better. There's a lot of
Dante's Inferno here, characters on a spiritual journey through a barren wasteland filled with desperate souls that have factionalized in order to improve their chances oand, perhaps, survive the journey to, ostensibly, paradise. Early on, there's even a wall with the words 'Abandon Hope All Ye Who Enter Here' that Scarlet and her sole companion, HIbiji (a paramedic from modern day Japan, as the Otherworld exists outside of time and space, so people from all over history and the world can end up here), come across at the infancy of their journey.
This film was NOT what I was expecting it to be. I was thinking that, other than Hibiji (who I initially assumed was 'isekai'd' into Scarlet's world), it was going to be a feudal adventure story set in 16th century Denmark with some fantasy elements. Instead what I got was something more existential and spiritual. That doesn't mean I suddenly became more passionate about the film. I remained an interested observer just willing to let the story come to me. In this respect, it's very much like watching something by Werner Herzog, but don't take that to mean that I put this on the level of his best works. The film expects you to take a 'wait and see' approach rather than theorycrafting or trying to understand the narrative as it goes. Maybe there's a lesson in there about how people tend to craft narratives. I don't really know.
Mana Ishida is FANTASTIC as Scarlet. She really brings it with this performance and is the clear standout here. I was completely impressed with her. Everyone else ranges from very good to serviceable. They are mostly 'good to average anime cast.' But man, Mana is tremendous in this movie.
The CGI in the trailer was offputting to me but, somehow, I liked the textures on the characters on the big screen and they felt like they had more 'grit' when writ large. Makes me wonder how the
Berserk 2012 trilogy would have looked to my eyes on a big screen, and I think that this film needs to be experienced in a theater to truly appreciate the vision of its director, Mamoru Hosoda (
Summer Wars, The Girl Who Leapt Through Time, Mirai and others). The story itself is mature and dark, addressing humanity's inability to put aside its own grievances in order to break the Hobbsian cycle and talks a lot about the elevation of the self's ambitions over the needs of the many and the common good. This is never more evident than in the primary obstacle Scarlet and Hibiji face on their own journey to the Infinite Land: her uncle Claudius, who also ended up in the Otherworld (along with all of his conspirators) and has organized the lost souls there into an army to gatekeep the entrance to paradise. He is waiting for his wife (the one he stole from his brother Amleth and, yes, the story is inspired by
Hamlet) to die and end up there so they can leave together. His ambition to keep others out of a place that he considers his own and not share it with those of lesser status is at the heart of the kind of human selfishness Hosoda is directly addressing. We could all live happier if those that made decisions about civilization were concerned with making everyone's lives better.
I wouldn't call the film thought provoking or revolutionary and it becomes strangely sentimental in the third act but perhaps that's appropriate, given the themes and what Hosoda believes is missing in so many of us, which is less 'kindness' and more 'self awareness'. I also wouldn't call any of its twists surprising.
What I will say is that Hosoda is absolutely right about this: the first step towards breaking the cycle is forgiveness. Someone needs to be able to forgive in order to lay their animus down. Simply choosing not to pursue it just leaves it to fester, grow and infect one all over again, itself a sort of personal, internalized Hobbsian cycle.
But the real question Hosoda is asking is: who, exactly, needs to be forgiven in such cases? And by who?
I will give it a 3.75 out of 5. Not quite a 4 but better than a 3 or even a 3.5.
Here is a trailer: