The Dreadful
A period piece taking place in the mid 15th century at the end of the Wars of the Roses, the focus is on Anne (Sophie Turner) and Morwen (Marcia Gay Harden) as a mother and daughter-in-law awaiting the return of Seamus (Anne's husband, Laurence O'Fuarain) from the war. It is their hope that Seamus will return home and help deliver them out of poverty and starvation but hopes go south when it is Jago (pronounced 'Yago', Kit Harrington), Anne's childhood friend who went to the war with Seamus, that returns and delivers the bad news that he is the only one returning. From there, the story is really about how Seamus' death affects all three of them and sends them into a spiral of violence, suspicion and lies. But there is another presence, a knight in black armor with a spined helmet that doesn't speak and only shows himself at a distance and whose appearances foretell ominous tidings.
The movie is a slow burn and your mileage will largely depend on how much you like films that require you to interpret what you're seeing and the ability to understand the characters mostly through what is shown rather than what is told. This is NOT a movie for the 'second screen viewing' generation and those with short attention spans who are easily distracted will be lost and uninterested before too long. Who Anne, Morwen and Jago are and your interest in the suspense of their mysteries, along with the meaning behind the black knight on a white horse, require investment from the audience.
This film plays with the same general 'vibe' and pace of an A24 pic or Robert Eggers'
The Witch but doesn't have the same kind of always present tension. This is more a story about straying from morality, becoming lost in the anarchy of the world and falling prey to one's own vices. There IS a supernatural element here but unfortunately, it doesn't feel very necessary to tell the story. The black knight is a metaphor for the excesses of immorality but I think it would have worked better as a pure character study absent this element. That's not to say that the black knight doesn't work as a narrative device, only that while not taking away anything, it didn't really add anything.
I felt that the strongest element of this film is how it kept me guessing as far as the characters go. Who is lying? Who is telling the truth? Who can be trusted? The motivations are very well written and a good foundation for the plot to have some substance.
The performances are pretty good, with Marcia Gay Harden being the standout, Sophie Turner showing a little more depth than I expected and Kit Harrington doing well enough without being very remarkable (par for the course for him). I will give him credit when he and Sophie are on the screen together because they have decent chemistry.
3.5 out of 5. It's fine for fans of costume dramas and period pieces like me but it isn't going to win any awards. Free with Amazon Prime.