OK guys, so I knew something like this was going to happen, and I just want to clarify what I have done and what has said about the kit too.
We already know about the Too Many Games scenario- Cdamm offered for the kit, and Jon and company gave me an idea of how much it would be. Just the idea, not a solid price. I did think that I would get more from what was being offered, especially with me collecting complete, matching kits. He tried working with me to sell the kit to someone that was interested in it, but it was a no go for the seller. I just didn't pursue selling the kit after that.
So I continued last year on finding an idea on prices. So on October 1st, 2015, I got a straightforward answer from Yagyu Jubei that the kit in Japanese was about $600 and the English version was $75-800 bucks. He edited and stated that:
"At this point the seller can charge what he wants since matching kits are rare." Read the new "what it's worth" thread
http://www.neo-geo.com/forums/showthread.php?240910-The-all-new-What-s-it-worth-thread/page41
I also got feedback from Wyo in regards to the kit too, and so I followed what the majority told me what I could get for it. I wanted to go through the forum on here and sell it, rather than on eBay because I want this kit to go to an established forum member (ex. member since 2000-2008, respectable post count, etc).
OK, full disclosure.
While running my booth at Too Many Games, another member, Stefan, approached me and asked me to come over to Windy Games's booth, saying it was important. I went over there and, with Chris, was Cold Wolf and his TSS kit. I was asked what he could possibly get for it...of course, asking the big question "do the serials match"...they did. Granted, I didn't notice the damage on the label (which is minor)...the mini-marquee was yellowed...not "sunfaded to hell" as someone else said earlier. (You didn't hold this in your hand, I did)
So, my thought was that what he had was pushing $1000. I had bought a complete TSS kit (US) from Shawn in the Neo Store over 10 years ago. IIRC, it was $600. In that item's case, the serial numbers didn't match either. Regardless of condition, the length of time since I bought my kit, he could possibly be looking at much more. If this were Nintendo Age, he'd be looking at a ton more, it's not, I get it.
Cdamm basically called me over to ask what he should pay for it. My response was "high 3 figures". I didn't get into a specific dollar amount, that was between Coldwolf and Cdamm. I even suggested he might want to talk 8man, as this was right up his ally. Cdamm and Coldwolf continued to negotiate after I left that discussion. Later on, Cdamm came by my booth and said that he probably wouldn't be getting the kit. He told me what the offer was but, I won't reveal that here, or, any of the other specifics of that deal. I will say it was a lot less than I thought it would go for...but, keep in mind, Cdamm runs a business, and has to make a profit.
So, I could possibly be "the idiot" who gave him the idea that his game was worth that much. If anyone here has any other past sales of complete US kits with matching serials ready to be linked to now might be a good time to post them. Otherwise, I stand by my "pushing $1000" estimate.
Basically, a lot of what I've been reading has been from a lot of people that want the item (badly, by the way) but, aren't willing to make a reasonable offer.
To coldwolf, I say if you don't get a serious offer by the end of the week, just list it on ebay. As for starting bid, start with what you paid and see where it goes.
Jon
Thanks for the disclosure and advice, Jon.
I think that you guys were caught off guard when you saw the kit tbh. You didn't think that I was going to pull out one out of my book bag. It could make sense in that aspect. I don't think that your estimate was far fetched, Jon, as I mentioned what another member said, and that's how I looked at it. I went with what a majority of members stated to me about the kit, and listed it at $1400.
Knowing that $1400 was WAY out of the pricing, I did adjust for that sake.
I already e-mailed Shawn about the kit and he gave me his offer on it. I know that the price would be $2500 for the complete TSS kit when he relists it. This kit would rot before he sells it. I'm not selling it for that much though, anyways.
I don't like the idea of the kit going on eBay because they stand by the buyer more than they do the seller. Flat out, I don't want to go that route unless if I have to.
I will tell members that so far, Cdamm had the higher number on the kit (I am looking at your original offer of what you offered me at TMG), and I will talk to him if other members don't want to add their two cents. Tyranix offered me slightly lower, but also included trades with cash. Just told him I'm looking at cash more than trades and cash.
Wyo, I appreciate the feedback and the real talk about the kit. I just want to see if there are any other offers that will come up. If anything, I will do what's appropriate. In the meantime, I want to give people a chance to throw in their offers before I do anything.