Earlier on I said I'd post some thoughts on
Gad Guard once I'd watched enough of it, well, regardless of wether anyone cares or not, I've taken in the first 10 episodes, and here are my thoughts.......
Its good, very good.... or should that be supprisingly good, seeings as the first disk was a bit of an impulse buy.
The initial premise - that of young 'hip-n-trendy' kids running around with highly-marketable-looking giant robots - kinda made me cringe, and for the first half of the first episode thats what I was doing (cringing) as I watched the main hero and his buddies racing arround town, skating between cars and generally trying to look 'hip' and 'rad'.
Bleugh!
But soon enough things got interesting. The main character stopped acting like a prick, and a couple more interesting characters made an appearance, and of course, the Gad's (the big robot-thingys) started showing up and doing battle with other big robot-thingys (referred to as Heavy-Metals).
What really makes Gad Guard shine is its sense of style and pacing. Not only is the animation during the fight-scenes very slick, its also cut very well to give the scenes that extra 'punch'. The same is true for the rest of the show, with a variety of interesting camera-angles and cuts being used during scenes of tension or danger. It gives the show a feeling of rapid pacing that I've rarely seen in anime.
The story? Meh, its standard anime stuff I guess. Teenagers find giant robots and use them to battle evil, while also trying to uncover the origins and true motives of the robots. Its a plot I've seen before many times, but -as ever in anime- its given a decent enough spin and packaged in a different setting (think 1940's America only with more advanced technology) to make things seem fairly fresh.
So yea, its pretty damn good. It looks great (typical great animation from Gonzo), has a nice cast of predictable-yet-likable characters, a fairly unique setting, and great pacing.
Dont let the fact that the primary cast are all 16-year-olds put you off.
And next up is
S-Cry-ed, which I wasnt going to bother with at first, but now that its out in a lovely box-set I figured that it would serve as ample backlog.
Its.......ummm.....errrr.......welll.....Its ok I guess.
Well, I've only seen the first 5 episodes so far, so mabye I'm judging it a bit early, but I'm really not 'sold' on this series (Well, technically speaking I am sold on it - I bought it after all - what I mean is, I havent really been able to 'click' with the sharacters and settings).
OK, so what are the basics of the show? Well, it centres around the idea of certain humans possesing the ability to summon an 'Alter'. Which is basically a special ability, it could be anything. For the main hero his 'Alter' is for his right arm to turn into a power-arm, other characters can summon huge guns, others summon beings that fight for them (Like 'Stands' in Jojo's Bizzare Adventure).
What makes things slightly interesting is that these 'Alters' are formed out of neerby substances (the ground, or buildings, or vehicles), so whenever someone wants to fight using one, they have to sacrifice part of their surroundings to summon it. This means they have to be carefull if summoning one in, say, a hospital.
The basic setting for all of this is a chunk of japan that has been cut off from the mainland due to some disaster, and is now mostly a no-go area for anyone that can afford to not live there. So its all half-ruined buildings and wateland mostly.
However, there is a small well-maintained walled-off city that still has law and order, and the organisation that runs it is looking to expand into the wasteland.
And thats where the inevitable conflict arises from, between our generic-anime-hero (who is a waselander) and the organisation called 'Holy' that is attempting to expand into the wastelands and also capture any rogue 'Alters' due to the danger they pose.
Holy isnt an intrinsically evil organisation, but contains a number of rotten eggs that enjoy repressing the wastelanders, and others that simply seem misguided. So you have a conflict where both sides are likeable to a degree, and there is no clear-cut sense of 'one side is good and the other is evil' which always makes things a tad more interesting.
But the show just seems very average somehow.
The character designs are average, the animation is mostly average (with spots of CGI used for special effects), and the pacing and setting seem somehow very average.
And the idea of people with special powers doing battle with each other....geez, how many times have I seen that done before?
S-Cry-ed's problem isnt that it's unoriginal at its core (most anime is like that), but that it fails to put enough of a spin on a well-worn genre to make it truly stand out.
The moment I saw the first 'Alter' being summoned I just thought to myself 'Ho hum, its one of these shows is it', and so far, I havent been supprised by anything that has happened.
Its not
bad per se, its just totally flat-out average.
Mabye it'll get better in subsequent disks............