I've been buying my stuff from
www.gateplay.com
They're one of the ones advertised at the top of the BGG home page. I chose them because they are quite competitive in price, and had the lowest 'free shipping' requirement at $100. The only thing is that the selection is smaller than most, so in a couple months I'll be out of stuff to buy from them.
I just got a Martin Wallace game,
Toledo. Themed in 16th century Toledo, Spain, players build the best swords to present to the King (Emporer?) of Spain.
This is quite a fast paced game. The game board is basically a track similar to Caylus, a winding road. Players can lay down businesses on this road as an action, and then either land their pieces on those businesses, or use other players businesses at the cost of movement cards. Movement cards double as money in this game. So what you do is land on a business that gives you steel, or a gem, and you build up your supply of these goods then eventually you can have a sword crafted for you by landing on the Swordmaker business tiles.
There is a little bit of player interaction thrown in. If you want to use a business that is occupied by an opponent, you can challenge them to a duel which is solved by flipping over cards in the movement card deck. The cards all have a picture of two guys fencing, with either the attacker or defender highlighted, which tells you who wins that round. Best 2 of 3 wins the duel, the loser gets sent back to the Cathedral (Start).
It's a quick playing, easy game to learn. Nice artwork on the board. This one at most places is $40 online. You can get a lot more bang for your buck than this game, but I do think it is fun. Probably would be a decent gateway game to non-gamers.