Saw two movies this weekend, one was excellent, the other very good:
Milk -- I'd been looking forward to this, I hoped it would be good.
The trailer was very promising. They timed the LA/NY debut to the 30th anniversary of the assassination. It just so-ended up timing with the Prop 8 battle... The opening batch of LA/NY reviews were tremendous, so I went in with high expectations. Finally saw it on Friday and it met expectations: this is one of the best movies of the year. Sean Penn completely disappears into the role of Harvey Milk; this isn't Jamie Foxx's performance as Ray Charles, this is a man playing a person most people aren't familiar with and making him seem like a completely "3-D" individual. IMO, if Mickey Rourke in The Wrestler ends up as good as he's been touted, this could be the 2-man race for the Best Actor Oscar. I was familiar with Harvey Milk's bio, and this movie does an excellent job of taking a lot of events and condensing them into key scenes that don't in any way feel like you're watching a set of Cliff Notes. They story is surprisingly focused and, while it deals with civil rights, it doesn't try to become too sweeping --Gus Van Sant did a good job of keeping things in check. A definite
5/5, must-see.
J.C.V.D. -- I've been hyping this movie up in my head for weeks since I
saw the trailer last month. I mean... Jean Claude Van Damme as Jean Claude Van Damme, a desperate, former-action hero caught in a bank robbery? This movie is closer to Dog Day Afternoon, and it holds nothing back in bringing up his drug problems, his infamous French-language interviews where he started babbling about pseudo-philosophy like being "aware" (mind you, he kept saying he was "aware" in English --here's a parody video that
captures that moment), and adapting his family and professional problems into a story set in the present day on a visit to his home town in Belgium. The movie has two incredible long takes: the first is an opening action sequence that is exceptional by any standard; the second is a long-take monologue where JCVD, breaking the 4th wall, basically gives a brutally honest assessment of his own life, its failures, and his aspirations. Those two scenes alone make this worth watching --there's welcome bit of fan service towards the end, but the movie itself goes a surprisingly honest route to the end. I saw it with 8 people from here and work, and I think its safe to say we all liked it. I probably give it a bit more than the others. If you're into Van Damme, its a 5/5 (and you've probably already figured out where its playing or pre-ordered the DVD), but as a movie I felt its a strong
4/5 --excellent if you're familiar with JCVD's earlier work.
I don't think you can go wrong seeing either of the above, or Slum Dog Millionaire which I think stands up with Milk as the two best movies I've seen this year (edging out Dark Knight by a bit).