Smoke if you like Booker's I HIGHLY suggest you check out Old Grandad 114. Also made by Beam and is the same mashbill as Booker's with a nice high proof. Tastes pretty much exactly the same but comes in around $20-25. Get in there.
Also lemme get your leftover blanton's
The Blantons is really growing on me...it's super smooth neat.
Per your recommendation, while I was up in Chicago I found a bottle of the Old Grandad 114. Paid $22 for it.
Good stuff, super spicy and the high proof packs a wallop. I'm going to compare it to Bookers tonight. Straight smell, the Bookers is softer...which is odd figuring it has much spice to it.
Either way, $22/bottle for 114 proof bourbon that doesn't taste like shit is a good deal...
*EDIT*
Ok...sat down with the two yesterday, side by side. I begin with the thought that they both need some water, the OGD is hot...the Booker's is silly hot. Just too much to really take it all in neat.
As for the taste...they're darn near completely different. OGD is sweeter, spicy, high rye taste. Booker's is also spicy as all hell, ton's of cinnamon in there...but the barrel flavor is completely different than OGD. That's what hit's you first with Booker's, the barrel. OGD does have an odd "bitter" aftertaste to it as well.I noticed that there first time I had it and it was there again last night.
In the end, the OGD is good...tons of bite, tons of spice. 100% you thing if you're into rye (I am not). All things being equal, for the same price (or less), I can get Weller Antique 107...being "wheated", its so much softer and more caramel.
It's a good buy though, especially figuring the proof. I'll probably make some seriously strong cocktails with it. I bet it will be superb in an old fashioned.