The least he could do is play the game to a decent level then state an oppinion. Its obvious to me that he played the game for about an hour & he new he was shit & he stopped playing because he forgot what real gamers standard was & went off to play some easy ass xbox/ps2 game that was more his level.
Besides you cant rate good fighting games because we constantly get better at them which makes them even more fun, if people rated a fighting game after only a week of playing then thats madness.
You can rate the game after only a good few years, so where do you go if they gave a fighting game 90% & people where only scratching the serface of it. People get so good at them that they triple there skills if not more, a fighting games limits are the players, shit players can mean shit game, the better the standard of players the more you need to learn to beat them.
Then the game must be-able to be flexible but not broken to let our minds run faster so we can confuse the opponent.