What's worse, NGF or Emulation?

BJMFH

Morden's Lackey
Joined
Oct 3, 2000
Posts
364
I was talking about this with one of my fellow vidiots. We haven't been able to reach a conclusion. What do you people think?
 

Kiel

All About Shooters Mod., If you fuck with me, I'll
20 Year Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2001
Posts
7,804
Man, thats like saying would you rather get kicked in the junk or punched in the junk.
 

Scalpeur

Genam's Azami Sharpener
Joined
May 19, 2001
Posts
1,521
lol Robert!
;)

More seriously I think there is a difference!
People playing with emulated games know they are playing with emulated games whereas SNK fans playing with NGF games don't know if it's an official Game or a Bootleg even if they paid for an OFFICIAL GAME(for most of them)!!

So for my part The worst is NGF Because they are liing to the customers!!

NGF, GO TO HELL!!!
...AND EMULATORS TOO!!!

<img src="graemlins/veryangry.gif" border="0" alt="[Very Angry]" />
 

Force

Zantetsu's Blade Sharpener
20 Year Member
Joined
Sep 1, 2000
Posts
2,439
They're both given way more credit then deserved for "ruining" the neo geo, and both aren't worth worrying about (at least as much as some of the people on these boards do).

Matt
 

BC_Gambit

Beni,
Joined
Dec 25, 2001
Posts
936
Force is right:

Emulation is used by and large by people who woudn't buy the AES/MVS games even if they were below $10 and shipping was free (i.e. extremely casual or extremely poor gamers... I was poor in College/University).

NGF actually does the "Elite" gamers who already have their collections complete a favour.

Every cart NGF defaces is one less on the market for serious collectors. Yay laws of supply and demand for raising the price of the remaining carts!!!
 

Force

Zantetsu's Blade Sharpener
20 Year Member
Joined
Sep 1, 2000
Posts
2,439
Originally posted by BC_Gambit:
<strong>Force is right:

Emulation is used by and large by people who woudn't buy the AES/MVS games even if they were below $10 and shipping was free (i.e. extremely casual or extremely poor gamers... I was poor in College/University).

NGF actually does the "Elite" gamers who already have their collections complete a favour.

Every cart NGF defaces is one less on the market for serious collectors. Yay laws of supply and demand for raising the price of the remaining carts!!!</strong><hr></blockquote>


WHile I share your views on emulation,, I think your views on NGF are pretty skewed. Destroying a collectable (especially one as short in demand as Neo geo) is a bad thing, and even tho I don't care if I get a cart/manual that has a sticker on it, lots of people out there do, and that's their perogative. This hobby is limited enough without people making "pure" carts even more scarce.

However, you'd think they were selling carts to fund the taliban the way this site talks about them. I the grand scheme of things, not that many carts passes through their hands, and NGF really is insignificant.

Matt
 

playboycougar

Reese. ,
Joined
Dec 8, 2001
Posts
2,637
Originally posted by Force:
<strong>They're both given way more credit then deserved for "ruining" the neo geo, and both aren't worth worrying about (at least as much as some of the people on these boards do).

Matt</strong><hr></blockquote>force i do agree with you on this post but i think your next one is flawed, it's true that we are both entitled to our opinions but i do think some people are blowing it out of proportion. now i dont think its a good idea to promote emulation but on the other hand it's not the root of all evil as some may think :D
 

aria

Former Moderator
Joined
Dec 4, 1977
Posts
39,546
Emulation is way, way, way lesser of an evil than NGF.

Destroying a Sac cart to make a new game is destroying a fixed amount of resources. When a cart is 'sacked', it's not coming back in it's original form.

Emulation deals with recordable and re-recordable data... Other than the ethical/financial dilemmas for some people, it has no where near the impact that destroying carts does.

And I don't just levy all the blame on NGF, I think all cart conversions are problematic.

To me,

People that convert carts are like the people that colorize black & white movies.

A special kind of evil that, as one of my old film professors said, have a special wing of hell waiting for them in the afterlife <img src="graemlins/veryangry.gif" border="0" alt="[Very Angry]" />
 

BC_Gambit

Beni,
Joined
Dec 25, 2001
Posts
936
It's not so much the number of carts that NGF defaces that pisses people off, its the fact their irreplaceable.

Even if the "only" deface 10 pristine carts a month, that's 120 carts a year... for the next 10 years that's over 1,000 carts.

That's still not a huge number by any means, but its a conservative estimate (judging by the amount of carts they SAY they sell :) ).

Sorry if my above post made me uncaring about NGF's destruction, I just honestly think it serves to make "pure" carts even more scarce, thus shooting the value of slugs, wolves, etc even higher.

Do you honestly think that Chris and Dion have defaced their own personal collections? Not a chance in hell :) .

Supply, demand and all that economic jazz play out wonderfully in collectible markets (like the AES... )

Blah, if anybody managed to read all of this, congrats :)
 

aria

Former Moderator
Joined
Dec 4, 1977
Posts
39,546
Originally posted by BC_Gambit:
<strong>Blah, if anybody managed to read all of this, congrats :) </strong><hr></blockquote>

I did, :D

Well said!
 

nick_th_fury

Baseball Star Hitter
Joined
Aug 29, 2000
Posts
1,266
Emulation is way, way, way lesser of an evil than NGF. <hr></blockquote>

The problem here, is that many people are very aware of emulation.
Pro or con.

However, the vast majority of SNK gamers, are not aware of why people dislike NGF soo much.

That's why Bonuskun & myself whipped up this handy little page.
So anytime someone asks, why do ya'll dislike ngf.
Rather than constantly repeating ourselves,
the answers just a link away.

<a href="http://home1.gte.net/res002b4/blues/ngf_blues.html" target="_blank">The NGF Bible</a>
 

aria

Former Moderator
Joined
Dec 4, 1977
Posts
39,546
Originally posted by nick_th_fury:
<strong>

That's why Bonuskun & myself whipped up this handy little page.
So anytime someone asks, why do ya'll dislike ngf.
Rather than constantly repeating ourselves,
the answers just a link away.

<a href="http://home1.gte.net/res002b4/blues/ngf_blues.html" target="_blank">The NGF Bible</a></strong><hr></blockquote>

Quoting Homer Simpson:

"Hmm... I find your views intriguing and would like to subscribe to your newsletter."

Would you and BonusKun mind if I hosted it here too? (with the appropriate acknowledgements and URL to the original source?)

[ January 22, 2002: Message edited by: Bobak ]</p>
 

Viewpoint

Art of Typing Wiz, , ,
25 Year Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2000
Posts
6,816
Yeah In general I think this link here points out what a lot of us have been trying to say without so much hate directed at the duo.

Their own actions speak for themselves which is more than enough. :)
 

Viewpoint

Art of Typing Wiz, , ,
25 Year Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2000
Posts
6,816
Originally posted by Bobak:
<strong>

Quoting Homer Simpson:

"Hmm... I find your views intriguing and would like to subscribe to your newsletter."

Would you and BonusKun mind if I hosted it here too? (with the appropriate acknowledgements and URL to the original source?)
</strong><hr></blockquote>

Bah I'm not here for credit on it....much. :D

Sides there were a few others who contributed as well, If you're going to give some credit, NeoRasa also deserves a bit for his joyous description of the King of Crump 2000 :D

[ January 22, 2002: Message edited by: BonusKun ]</p>
 

evil wasabi

The Jongmaster
25 Year Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2000
Posts
60,434
Basicaly NGF will cost you money,they rip people off and money is stolen,
emulation however of neo-geo games currently cannot rip off anyone cos its free and the company is technically dead,at the most its ripping off the company but if there not around anymore,whos gonna care itll go on no matter what.

Ultimatly doing either is a bad move if you want neo-geo games.
 

FeelGood

So Many Posts
No Time
For Games.
Joined
Aug 18, 2001
Posts
17,794
Emulation can be considered criminal in the sense of license and such, but it offers netplay, and on a fast enough connection with a good enough controller and computer (pentium 2s are good enough), I feel that emulation isn't as "bad" as it used to be. I mean, I'm all for paying for my goods, but what if the "goods" as I want them (neogeo games with netplay) can only be acquired through emulation? Eh, guess I have to bite teh bullet.

(I still think people who come here just to start threads saying "romz are good - emulation didn't kill SNK!" are jackasses)

NGF destroys actual goods. They are like the chinese communist army destroying icons in buddhist temples. They are the Nazis burning books in Germany. That and they are FUCKING MORONS!
 

evasyar

Genjuro's Frog,
Joined
Aug 21, 2001
Posts
1,193
...err hello nick_th_fury:

just want to thank you for the link about the ngf bible. it was definitely a great read for me and clinched yet again as to why people like me should not deal with the "freaky duo". thanks amillion for relaying this!! :o
 

chrisr

Known Scammer and One Deluded Individual, NeoGeoFr
20 Year Member
Joined
Nov 2, 2000
Posts
653
One of my favoites:

"Dion's poor business practices start to surface. He tries to purchase the entire stock of Metal Slug X carts from SNK USA"

Hmm.. someone wants to buy your ENTIRE stock of carts but you wont sell them? Sounds like a formula for bankruptcy for me!

Flash to the present.........

"Someone wants to play Bigtymer and purchases the entire stock of Metal Slug 3 carts from the US distributor, a company smart enough to actually sell product when they have a chance"

Stories sound very similar dont they?

The worst part is they look like the greatest thing since sliced bread, while sticking a poor unknowledgeable fan with stock that is languishing. To make it even WORSE they get away with it AGAIN with a title that should have never been released, Sengoku 3.

Its all pretty funny and sad all at the same time.

But... The best is yet to come!

Thanks,

ChrisR

"Just wait till you see whats next"
 

Rade K

Ned's Ninja Academy Dropout
20 Year Member
Joined
Mar 17, 2001
Posts
11,835
Originally posted by chrisr:
<strong>One of my favoites:

"Dion's poor business practices start to surface. He tries to purchase the entire stock of Metal Slug X carts from SNK USA"

Hmm.. someone wants to buy your ENTIRE stock of carts but you wont sell them? Sounds like a formula for bankruptcy for me!

</strong><hr></blockquote>

They(SNK USA) we're looking out for the best interest of the customer in this case. Why sell all the stock to a person who is going to mark them up and raise the price? I know SNK's game buying fan base wasnt the largest back then it isnt now either) but I don't think they wanted to piss of the little support they had by cheating customers like that. One of SNK USA's few smart moves.

Sure, there might have been a good chance to sell all carts and make some cash for once, but why sell your soul to the devil?
 

Big Bruno

,
20 Year Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2000
Posts
1,539
Originally posted by chrisr:
One of my favoites:

"Dion's poor business practices start to surface. He tries to purchase the entire stock of Metal Slug X carts from SNK USA"

Hmm.. someone wants to buy your ENTIRE stock of carts but you wont sell them? Sounds like a formula for bankruptcy for me!

<hr></blockquote>

Actually chris if I recall this was around the time Dion was trying to sell his entire NGH collection on Ebay. I remember him complaining later about how SNKUSA lied to him and the Metal slug x release was bigger then what he was orginally told and he was no longer going to be able to purchase it. Therefore he never was able to purchase all the games as planed. I am personally very glad he did not since I enjoy having a red striped Metal slug X instead of an oddball orange one.

Since you seem so eager to address these points please do it one by one and not selectively choose which points you wish to dispute. Also maybe you can answer once and for all why you guys lied about the orange stripes in the first place. But I am sure you will avoid this like you always do.

At any rate please make whatever "Big Tymer Exclusive" release, rare proto find or new neo game exclusive right or whatever announcement on your site. With all the customers you have I am sure you do not need to promote yourself with this fan site.
 

chrisr

Known Scammer and One Deluded Individual, NeoGeoFr
20 Year Member
Joined
Nov 2, 2000
Posts
653
Your selective memory is flawed. The fact is SNK had a chance to sell them all in one shot. They failed as usual, because the company was being run by people were idiots, as I think everyone knows by now. So, they ended up having to blow them out with the other "closeout" carts they had at 180 each I think.

I'm glad your happy with your "red striped" MSX. It meshes PEFECTLY with the other 3 MS carts huh?

You can twist words all you want, but what I find so funny is you quote a private email between Dion and I that I posted to the list when I was in Europe. As much as people dont believe, ask Joe who has seen it himself, all my carts are genre corrected.

The "faq", which took up hours of someone's obviously "exciting" life is so twisted its reaching "fable" status.

I wouldnt waste my time typing out explainations for each point, since the blind fury would prevent the truth from being buried in garbage, but I will tell you this:

I cant WAIT for the bomb to drop on one of them. It will be a true pleasure to see what explanations you try to come up with to explain this one.

good luck.

ChrisR

"Just wait till you see whats next"

Originally posted by Big Bruno:
<strong>

Actually chris if I recall this was around the time Dion was trying to sell his entire NGH collection on Ebay. I remember him complaining later about how SNKUSA lied to him and the Metal slug x release was bigger then what he was orginally told and he was no longer going to be able to purchase it. Therefore he never was able to purchase all the games as planed. I am personally very glad he did not since I enjoy having a red striped Metal slug X instead of an oddball orange one.

Since you seem so eager to address these points please do it one by one and not selectively choose which points you wish to dispute. Also maybe you can answer once and for all why you guys lied about the orange stripes in the first place. But I am sure you will avoid this like you always do.

At any rate please make whatever "Big Tymer Exclusive" release, rare proto find or new neo game exclusive right or whatever announcement on your site. With all the customers you have I am sure you do not need to promote yourself with this fan site.</strong><hr></blockquote>
 

FTL

AES Price Guide Analyst, International Moderator,
Staff member
Joined
Sep 27, 2000
Posts
2,498
Originally posted by chrisr:
As much as people dont believe, ask Joe who has seen it himself, all my carts are genre corrected.


<hr></blockquote>

Wow,that's pure junk then!
 

Big Bruno

,
20 Year Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2000
Posts
1,539
Chris I always enjoy debating with you..

There was never an oppertunity to purchase them all in one shot, only the hope.

As far as a private email that was posted to the list? So what are you are telling me you and dion believed there were these magical orange striped european NGH's floating around ;)

All those facts are true and there is the data to back them up as well, which is why you can not debate them.

But really if you have truley Trancended SNK why are you spending so much time promoting yourself here. I never recall SNK saying "hey look what we are releaseing or have" on websites other then their own in the past. it was always Press releases or promotion from fans.

As I stated on the DHP. You guys could be named SNKNEOGEOUSA for all I care, it will not change my oppinion or views on you and truthfully I could care less on whatever release your are coming out with. I along with several other take pride in being 100% NGF free.

I think the feeling comes from knowing none of the money I spend on the neo is going towards the willfull destruction of Neo products and it spent towards companies that support the fans and the neo.

You know come to think of it !arcade! does not post here anymore either since they have thier own site. Maybe one day you to will reach that level where you can relay on Neo fans to say "hey look at the great products coming from NGF". I think you realize though that will never happen.

Don't you have around 1000 NGF to stamp?
 

nick_th_fury

Baseball Star Hitter
Joined
Aug 29, 2000
Posts
1,266
since the blind fury would prevent the truth <hr></blockquote>

Haha,
thats always a good 'ol stand by aint it.

Funny though, other than buyright.com, ngf seems to be the only Neo reseller that gets "blind fury" directed toward them.
Wonder why that is?

[ January 22, 2002: Message edited by: nick_th_fury ]</p>
 
Top