C
Caris Nautilus
Guest
This is a report from kiselgof comparing the Jap KOF 2k cart, And the english NGF KOF 2k cart. These are just selections from the report, The full report can be seen here:
http://members.aol.com/makiselgof/graphics/report.doc
"""""Inspection Criteria
The following materials were evaluated in preparation of this report:
· KOF2000 AES USA cart from NGF (box, insert, manual, bag, cart w/sticker)
· KOF2000 AES Japanese cart from NCS (box, insert, manual, bag, cart w/sticker)
· KOF1999 AES USA cart from SNK-USA (box, insert, manual, cart w/sticker)
· Metal Slug 3 AES Japanese cart from NCS (box, insert, manual, cart w/sticker)
This report is based strictly on the physical observations of the above materials only. No other criteria, including but not limited to past history of NGF-USA, verbal information from NGF-USA or other members, or other materials not present in my possession, was included in the generation of this report.
The results point to an unusually larger size in the KOF2000 USA version of the insert. An analysis of the DPI printing procedures was conducted in the KOF2000 USA and JP versions using a 4x magnifying glass. An area 13mm in length on the back of the insert with the portrait of the Vanessa character was used as a sample. The analysis indicated that the print pattern of the KOF2000 USA version was different from the JP version with an estimated ratio of 3:2 in terms of black circular dot patterns. The paper-weight of the KOF2000 USA was approximately 1pt. higher than the other inserts, utilizing a rough scale of Xerox glossy paper grading. The overall gloss and color DPI on the USA insert was richer and included less green hues and more red hues compared to the JP insert. The NEO-GEO logo on the spine and the Meg Count Box both had a discrepancy in the form of jagged, linear edges on the curvatures of the letters and numbers. None of the other SNK-Japan produced versions had this discrepancy and instead featured smooth curvatures. The SNK blue logo did not have a discrepancy in terms of the jaggedness but featured a discrepancy in the form of horizontal lines of black dots in the blue background, viewed under the 4x magnification. The other three SNK-Japan produced versions featured lines of black dots slanted at a ~25% angle from the vertical. The serial number for the game was presented as NGH-2571, the correct terminology for this version. The overall image of the KOF2000 USA insert is presented in Picture 1.
The binding on the KOF2000 USA manual was skewed by about 1mm on the back half of the pages. The binding staples were shorter that those of the JP manual version. The paper-weight of the KOF2000 USA version was higher than the JP version, with the paper being whiter and glossier on all ensuing middle pages. The binding process and the difference in paper quality contributed to a wider radius for the USA manual when left in a free-opened state as illustrated in Picture 2.
The SNK blue logo on the cover of the KOF2000 USA manual was missing the registered trademark symbol but was comparable to the KOF1999 USA manual in this regard.
The blue logo on the cover of the KOF2000 USA manual featured a discrepancy in the form of horizontal lines of black dots in the blue background, viewed under 4x magnification. The other three SNK-Japan produced versions featured lines of black dots slanted at a ~25% angle from the vertical. The blue logo and descriptive lettering on the cover of the KOF2000 USA manual also featured a discrepancy in the form of jagged, linear edges on the curvatures of the letters and numbers. The KOF2000 JP version, along with the other two SNK-Japan versions, featured smooth curvatures. An analysis of the bottom of the background on the inner manual pages was conducted using a 4x magnifying glass. The KOF2000 USA version had a lower concentration of black DPI in the background illustrations of Kyo and crispier white edges. Pages 4 and 5 of the KOF2000 USA version had a different font for page numbers from the rest of the pages and the same pages in the JP version. There was no vertical spine creasing on the KOF2000 USA version, a discrepancy with the other three versions, which all featured extensive vertical spine creasing indicating a lower quality and lower weight paper. The overall image of the KOF2000 USA manual is presented in Picture 3.
yellow warning-use label found on all USA market cartridges manufactured since 1996 and had a shadow that indicated the former presence of a gold sticker there that may have been removed. The KOF2000 USA cartridge sticker had a glossy feel similar to the insert and the manual cover and did not have the stain-resistant plastic gloss finish that was present on the three other versions examined. The lack of this plastic gloss finish also contributed to distinctly crisp lettering in the Neo Geo logo symbol, something absent from the KOF1999 USA version. The KOF2000 USA cartridge sticker also featured a discrepancy in the form of square corners as opposed to rounded corners of the three other versions examined. The overall image of the KOF2000 USA cartridge is presented in Picture 4.
Having evaluated the above items, the following major observations have been made with regards to the KOF2000 AES USA version:
· The insert is of a higher and different quality, features a different color scheme and discrepancies in terms of jaggedness of rounded lettering and numbering.
· The manual is of a higher and different quality, features a different binding scheme and discrepancies in terms of jaggedness of rounded lettering and numbering.
· The cartridge is identical to the JP version but lacks the gold-warning label and features a discrepancy in terms of sticker cutting procedures and a lower and different quality sticker
The above-mentioned observations, in addition to the numerous observations mentioned in the body of this report lead to a conclusion that the NGF-USA distributed KOF2000 AES USA cartridge was not manufactured or produced by the same facility as the JP version. Furthermore, the presence of numerous discrepancies indicated above, leads to a conclusion that the NGF-USA distributed KOF2000 AES USA cartridge was not manufactured or produced by the same facility as the most recent USA and JP AES releases. The opinions and conclusions are provided with a reasonable degree of scientific certainty, are based on the material reviewed thus far, and may be amended or modified if additional information becomes available. Thank you for your time.
Sincerely,
Mikhail Kiselgof"""""
So it looks as if Dions cart is a high quality fake, What does everyone else think about this? Also notice that the ENGLISH 2k cart was added to the Master list as being official, You can all guess by who, Perhaps someone out there that bought the NGF cart is now dis mayed that it may be fake and wants to push it's validness anyway they can? you decide...
------------------
http://prizmdash.cjb.net
http://members.aol.com/makiselgof/graphics/report.doc
"""""Inspection Criteria
The following materials were evaluated in preparation of this report:
· KOF2000 AES USA cart from NGF (box, insert, manual, bag, cart w/sticker)
· KOF2000 AES Japanese cart from NCS (box, insert, manual, bag, cart w/sticker)
· KOF1999 AES USA cart from SNK-USA (box, insert, manual, cart w/sticker)
· Metal Slug 3 AES Japanese cart from NCS (box, insert, manual, cart w/sticker)
This report is based strictly on the physical observations of the above materials only. No other criteria, including but not limited to past history of NGF-USA, verbal information from NGF-USA or other members, or other materials not present in my possession, was included in the generation of this report.
The results point to an unusually larger size in the KOF2000 USA version of the insert. An analysis of the DPI printing procedures was conducted in the KOF2000 USA and JP versions using a 4x magnifying glass. An area 13mm in length on the back of the insert with the portrait of the Vanessa character was used as a sample. The analysis indicated that the print pattern of the KOF2000 USA version was different from the JP version with an estimated ratio of 3:2 in terms of black circular dot patterns. The paper-weight of the KOF2000 USA was approximately 1pt. higher than the other inserts, utilizing a rough scale of Xerox glossy paper grading. The overall gloss and color DPI on the USA insert was richer and included less green hues and more red hues compared to the JP insert. The NEO-GEO logo on the spine and the Meg Count Box both had a discrepancy in the form of jagged, linear edges on the curvatures of the letters and numbers. None of the other SNK-Japan produced versions had this discrepancy and instead featured smooth curvatures. The SNK blue logo did not have a discrepancy in terms of the jaggedness but featured a discrepancy in the form of horizontal lines of black dots in the blue background, viewed under the 4x magnification. The other three SNK-Japan produced versions featured lines of black dots slanted at a ~25% angle from the vertical. The serial number for the game was presented as NGH-2571, the correct terminology for this version. The overall image of the KOF2000 USA insert is presented in Picture 1.
The binding on the KOF2000 USA manual was skewed by about 1mm on the back half of the pages. The binding staples were shorter that those of the JP manual version. The paper-weight of the KOF2000 USA version was higher than the JP version, with the paper being whiter and glossier on all ensuing middle pages. The binding process and the difference in paper quality contributed to a wider radius for the USA manual when left in a free-opened state as illustrated in Picture 2.
The SNK blue logo on the cover of the KOF2000 USA manual was missing the registered trademark symbol but was comparable to the KOF1999 USA manual in this regard.
The blue logo on the cover of the KOF2000 USA manual featured a discrepancy in the form of horizontal lines of black dots in the blue background, viewed under 4x magnification. The other three SNK-Japan produced versions featured lines of black dots slanted at a ~25% angle from the vertical. The blue logo and descriptive lettering on the cover of the KOF2000 USA manual also featured a discrepancy in the form of jagged, linear edges on the curvatures of the letters and numbers. The KOF2000 JP version, along with the other two SNK-Japan versions, featured smooth curvatures. An analysis of the bottom of the background on the inner manual pages was conducted using a 4x magnifying glass. The KOF2000 USA version had a lower concentration of black DPI in the background illustrations of Kyo and crispier white edges. Pages 4 and 5 of the KOF2000 USA version had a different font for page numbers from the rest of the pages and the same pages in the JP version. There was no vertical spine creasing on the KOF2000 USA version, a discrepancy with the other three versions, which all featured extensive vertical spine creasing indicating a lower quality and lower weight paper. The overall image of the KOF2000 USA manual is presented in Picture 3.
yellow warning-use label found on all USA market cartridges manufactured since 1996 and had a shadow that indicated the former presence of a gold sticker there that may have been removed. The KOF2000 USA cartridge sticker had a glossy feel similar to the insert and the manual cover and did not have the stain-resistant plastic gloss finish that was present on the three other versions examined. The lack of this plastic gloss finish also contributed to distinctly crisp lettering in the Neo Geo logo symbol, something absent from the KOF1999 USA version. The KOF2000 USA cartridge sticker also featured a discrepancy in the form of square corners as opposed to rounded corners of the three other versions examined. The overall image of the KOF2000 USA cartridge is presented in Picture 4.
Having evaluated the above items, the following major observations have been made with regards to the KOF2000 AES USA version:
· The insert is of a higher and different quality, features a different color scheme and discrepancies in terms of jaggedness of rounded lettering and numbering.
· The manual is of a higher and different quality, features a different binding scheme and discrepancies in terms of jaggedness of rounded lettering and numbering.
· The cartridge is identical to the JP version but lacks the gold-warning label and features a discrepancy in terms of sticker cutting procedures and a lower and different quality sticker
The above-mentioned observations, in addition to the numerous observations mentioned in the body of this report lead to a conclusion that the NGF-USA distributed KOF2000 AES USA cartridge was not manufactured or produced by the same facility as the JP version. Furthermore, the presence of numerous discrepancies indicated above, leads to a conclusion that the NGF-USA distributed KOF2000 AES USA cartridge was not manufactured or produced by the same facility as the most recent USA and JP AES releases. The opinions and conclusions are provided with a reasonable degree of scientific certainty, are based on the material reviewed thus far, and may be amended or modified if additional information becomes available. Thank you for your time.
Sincerely,
Mikhail Kiselgof"""""
So it looks as if Dions cart is a high quality fake, What does everyone else think about this? Also notice that the ENGLISH 2k cart was added to the Master list as being official, You can all guess by who, Perhaps someone out there that bought the NGF cart is now dis mayed that it may be fake and wants to push it's validness anyway they can? you decide...
------------------
http://prizmdash.cjb.net