You guys have no idea about crappy fighting game casts! ;-)
Just to name a few:
Kasumi Ninja -- Jaguar
A scotsman who shoots fireballs from under his kilt.. need I say more?
Fight For Life -- Jaguar
A psychiatrist in hell chasing a patient? C'mon!
Ultra Vortek -- Jaguar
Even though I *liked* this game and it's choppy framerate.. it's a polished turd... awful. The designs look like Rubbermaid and Black and Decker gone awry.
MK1 -- Various
That game was another AWFUL AWFUL cast. I like the MK series, especially 2 & UMK3, but that cast is an abomination.
B.I.O.F.R.E.A.K.S -- PSX/n64/DC
AIGGHHHHH!!! I got this for xmas, TRIED to like this game, I really did, but man is the character design a total waste. There's one or two really good ones, but BLEAHHHH!!!!
World Heroes Series -- Arcade/Neo
You cannot tell me this games series is anything but awful in terms of style. Yeah, I'll get flamed, but man, some people will like anything.
Honorable Mentions:
Fighters History
Karnov's Revenge
Tekken 4
That Final Fantasy Fighting game
One must Fall
Sango Fighter
FX Fighter
Street Fighter
Eternal Champions
TMNT Tourney FIghters
Rise of the Robots
Primal Rage
Killer Instinct 2