Duran Duran wins for me purely on nostolgic grounds of it being the only tape I had while on a houseboat for a few weeks as a kid.
INXS had about 3 better than good songs total. They get points for the lead singer's colorful exit from the world, but not enough.
My girlfriend has never stopped liking Depeche Mode, and still listens to them so much that it's come to the point that I can't fucking stand their whiney angst for more that a 3-second burst per month. I liked them in junior high, but get over it. Life is not anywhere near that hopeless.